Client Comments | Mediation Offices of Floyd J. Siegal

If you would like to submit a testimonial for inclusion on this page, click here.

I recently had the opportunity to mediate a premises liability matter with Mr. Siegal. This was the second mediation. The first was with a different mediator. The case involved multiple defendants and some unusual injury issues and evidence. At the outset, the parties were very far apart in their liability evaluation and numbers. The defendants, too, had issues regarding indemnity under their respective services agreements. With his relaxed nature and effective perseverance, Mr. Siegal kept the parties at the table with an ultimately positive result. And if that was not good enough, and it was, he never said stop after the clock ran over and never charged us for the overage. And Mr. Siegal's generosity did not stop there. He also has a practice of donating a portion of his mediation fees to a charity of counsel's choice. This needs no further comment. I recommend Mr. Siegal for your next case whether you are plaintiff or defendant. He is bright, fair to all sides and works hard. That's all we can ask for.

Stuart Supowit, Esq.

Jackson, Jenkins & Renstrom

Floyd Siegal is a mediator with energy, enthusiasm, credibility, and a strong desire to never let a mediation end without a settlement being reached. His fresh approach to mediations is inspiring. I’ve attended too many mediations where the mediator simply “goes through the motions” and resolves nothing. But Floyd will keep the parties talking, present innovative ideas for settlement, and work as hard as anyone. I highly recommend Floyd Siegal as a mediator.

David Ring, Esq.

Taylor & Ring

I came late to the Floyd Siegal roll out. While I had heard from several people that Floyd was very good, we all develop a “comfort level” with a handful of mediators and frequently stay within a self-imposed “list” of mediators. Approximately three years ago, an adversary suggested Floyd and I decided to give him a chance; a decision I definitely do not regret. Floyd opened my eyes to his ability to listen and observe the situation (including what is truly driving the particular mediation), as well as his stealth persistence. I use the term "stealth" because it exemplifies Floyd’s pursuit in a course of action, in spite of difficulty or opposition, without any perceived force. Simply put, Floyd keeps a dialogue moving even when the parties claim they want to stop. Where other mediators feel they have reached an impasse, Floyd realizes this is where the work begins. Whether through a joint breakout session of counsel; allowing a party (not attorney) to merely speak, thereby allowing the party to feel that their position/feelings are validated; or post-session telephone calls, Floyd keeps people talking. Since the purpose of mediation is to find points of agreement, the more discussion the better. Now, after thee years, Floyd Siegal is on that list of mediators that fall within my “comfort level” and I do not hesitate to suggest him as a mediator to each of my adversaries.

Gerald DeSimone, Esq.

DeSimone & Huxster

Mr. Siegal is a fantastic neutral! I’ve brought two very tough cases before him (one a very high value and complex case) and through hard work, determination and a knack for thinking outside of the box, he got them both done. I also really appreciated his approach with my clients. He gave them a direct and informative real world perspective on their case, while also being incredibly compassionate. They appreciated it very much and raved about the job he did. I highly recommend Mr. Siegal and look forward to personally working with him again on many cases in the future!

Jacob L. Stipp, Esq.

Stipp Law Firm

My first contact with Floyd Siegal came a number of years ago, by way of an opposing counsel’s recommendation. I had heard good things about Mr. Siegal but had no way of validating any of them for myself at that time. I have since been able to, and many times over. My clients and I have always felt that he was genuinely involved in trying to resolve our case and that the facts of the case as we viewed them were being heard and respected. I have had mediations with Mr. Siegal where my clients have been extremely thankful for his efforts (even when a case did not settle during an initial session), with others tearfully embracing him for being able to bring closure for their heavy loss. Of the cases that I have mediated with Mr. Siegal, a majority of them have settled either on the day of mediation or within a few weeks thereafter. For those that remained, they too thereafter settled through his tireless ”after-hour” efforts to keep the parties talking. That is an important asset to me. As litigators, we agree to the mediation process in an effort to seek out a fair resolution for our clients where possible. For those cases that should resolve and can resolve regardless of difficulty, Floyd Siegal would be a perfect choice.

Mark Apelian, Esq,

Bryman & Apelian

The cases I have set for trial are tough to resolve. There’s a lot at stake and the injuries are so horrific that carriers don't know how to evaluate them. That’s where Floyd Siegal comes in. Floyd has settled more of my cases than any other mediator. He’s my go to mediator and at the top of my list every time!  

Steven R. Vartazarian, Esq.

The Vartazarian Law FIrm

Mr. Siegal loves baseball analogies, including his patented "Baseball Mediation.™" I think Mr. Siegal is a five-tool talented mediator. He starts with pre-mediation conferencing days before the mediation to understand the likely sticking issues before the formal session commences. The pre-conference absorbs the time-suck that usually exhausts the first few hours of mediation so when the mediation starts, everyone is ready to get down to brass tacks. Mr. Siegal is creative and tailors his mediations differently every time depending on case type and personalities. Mr. Siegal is facilitative, but in his own disarming and professional manner, is evaluative when appropriate to try to move the needle when appropriate. Mr. Siegal is tenacious to the end. And even better, your case is not forgotten as soon as the scheduled mediation ends without a settlement. Mr. Siegal's follow up post-mediation to try to close the matter is outstanding.

Marc Trachtman, Esq.

Trachtman & Trachtman

Floyd is an exceptional mediator. He does a fantastic job of comforting your client and explaining the process and keeping them involved. He is extremely honest in his process and stays with it until resolution. I highly recommend him and would use him on any case.

Siamak Vaziri, Esq.

Vaziri Law Firm

Mr. Siegal is a very personable and even-handed mediator. I would have bet my paycheck that the case he mediated for me would not settle. I would have lost that paycheck, as he managed to settle it. He was well informed about the case and facts and was creative in the tools he used to get us to the point where the case settled. His policy to donate a portion of his fee to the charity of one’s choice was impressive. He earned his fee and I would without hesitation recommend him to anyone on any side of the fence.

Mark D. Kaufman, Esq.

Mark R. Weiner & Associates

Just a quick note of thanks for getting this matter closed yesterday. I was very inclined to walk a couple of times and your persistence paid off. The case would not have settled but for your considerable influence on the parties, particularly the plaintiff and her counsel. We have not worked together in the past but I will certainly keep you in mind for matters in the future and have routed your resume to the attorneys throughout my firm.

Arthur J. Chapman, Esq.

Chapman, Glucksman, Dean & Roeb

Floyd is great. Have used him numerous times. He gets the job done, especially in the most difficult and challenging cases. His "Baseball Mediation™" alternative is both innovative and gets cases settled. I highly recommend Floyd.

Craig Roeb, Esq.

Chapman, Glucksman, Dean & Roeb

Floyd is absolutely one of the best mediators anyone can use. He is well-tempered, smart, and solution-oriented. He works hard to get the parties to consider each other's positions and employs outside the box thinking to overcome obstacles in resolving cases. He follows through on cases after mediation until they are resolved or there is no hope. Beyond his professionalism, his dedication, and intelligence, he is a caring and compassionate human being that has earned the respect of both sides of the bar.

P. Christopher Ardalan, Esq.

Ardalan & Associates

I commend Mr. Siegal's creative efforts as a mediator in a serious injury construction case. This case involved multiple parties and at the time of mediation two defendants' summary judgment motions were pending and two other defendants were in for the duration. The potential outcome of the MSJ's created different exposure to different defendants. Mr Siegal fashioned a formula that used the pending MSJ's as a tool to encourage the parties to ultimately reach a significant 7 figure settlement. Mr Siegal's phone follow-up between and after face-to-face mediation sessions was instrumental in keeping the parties engaged.

Steven B. Effres, Esq.

Effres & Associates

Thank you for going well above and beyond the call of duty to get this case resolved. I honestly did not think the gap would get closed - but you kept us all engaged in your creative process and it worked beautifully! I know that my client was impressed and pleased with the outcome and has already added you to its list of preferred neutrals.

Michael G. Martin, Esq.


Graves & King

Floyd Siegal understands what it means to be an effective mediator. He is compassionate with the plaintiffs and truly listens to their story. He is knowledgable about complex legal issues. Most of all he is very creative with his approach to resolving a case that is fair to both sides. All of my experiences with Floyd have been consistently great.

Robert Ounjian, Esq.

Carpenter, Zuckerman & Rowley

Debbie and I want to thank you for your excellent work today. This has been hanging over us for what seems an eternity, and the resolution in which you were so instrumental is a great relief for us. Now we can get on with our lives and in leaving this all behind us, find some peace from an event that changed so many things for us. Would you please direct our donated portion of your hard-earned fee to St. Jude’s Children’s Research Hospital? Again, thanks very much. Your clients are, I think, lucky to have you "on both sides.”

Debbie and David B.

Plaintiffs

Top tier mediator. Very resourceful. Hard working with great follow up. The follow up has resulted in and caused case resolution on matters that would not have resolved but for his persistence. My understanding is that the defense bar thinks highly of him.

Andrew Bryman, Esq.

Bryman & Apelian

Mr. Siegal was instrumental in settling a tough MIST case with seasoned counsel and difficult facts. The pre-litigation offer was in the low five figures. The case settled for six figures and above the pre-litigation demand. Mr. Siegal was patient and listened to the clients and determined their “needs” and “wants.” He brought a contemporary approach to mediation which was refreshing. He had both my clients' and my confidence. Although the mediation concluded without a settlement, Mr. Siegal worked the back channels to bring about a fair settlement within a few days. I would not hesitate to use him again. He has my vote of confidence and I have recommended him to others.

Minh T. Nguyen, Esq.

Law Offices of Minh T. Nguyen

Mr Siegal definitely lived up to his reputation as a great mediator. He was very effective and my client felt well treated by the process.

Alexandra Irons, Esq.

Law Offices of Baker & Oring

Mr. Siegal helped me to settle a particularly difficult case, knowing when to push and when to pull back. Fortunately, he was not inclined to give up on a settlement that seemed impossible.

Ray Dolen, Esq.

Brunick, McElhaney & Beckett

Mr. Siegal promised that he would follow-up with the attorneys after we left his office and he made good on that promise, eventually helping us craft a creative settlement.

Jeff Carlson, Esq.

Carlson & Messer

Floyd Siegal is the ideal mediator: thoughtful, intelligent, fair, respectful and thorough. He accomplished more in a few hours with his "shuttle diplomacy" than all the costly discovery that preceded the mediation. Most importantly, he knows how to close a deal.

Coe A. Bloomberg, Esq.

Jones Day

Floyd did a great job getting the parties together to understand the relative merits of their case, but was also able to advocate each side's position on issues important to that side's view of the case. He was frank about how the case would be perceived by a jury – and his realism made settlement a much more likely proposition. The best news was that we were able to persuade the other side to see the case our way!

Tyrone Maho, Esq.

Maho & Prentice

One of the elements that impressed me most during this process was Mr. Siegal’s calm and comforting demeanor. Most important, he was able to instill confidence and faith in the process of mediating for my client. And, while there is a tendency for the adversarial nature of the litigation to bleed into the mediation process, Mr. Siegal was able to keep the conversation and negotiation moving in a common direction, and ultimately assisted in the successful disposition of the matter.

Matthew D. Riojas, Esq.

Mr. Siegal brings a different approach to mediation. He is a uniquely good listener, and puts that skill to good use in bringing parties from far apart to agreement. I highly recommend him.

Guy Gruppie, Esq.

Murchison & Cumming

Thank you for sticking with our case for a full 360 days! It too is the longest case I have had in mediation and is a tribute to your perseverance. I look forward to many more mediations with you, but hopefully they won't last as long as this last one.

Jack D. Hull, Esq.


Goldsmith & Hull

Floyd was an excellent mediator. He was patient, even tempered yet forceful and knowledgeable. He was able to get the case settled quickly.

Rinat B. Klier Erlich, Esq.

Manning & Kass, Elrod, Ramirez, Trester

Thanks again for your efforts, and for restoring my faith in the mediation process. It was all about our client, and he seems to be content that it is all over. That’s what counts the most for me. You were pivotal in making our client happy. Thank you.

Frank Y. Ariel, Esq.

Floyd was suggested by defense counsel. I consented. I found him to be very prepared, thoughtful, engaged, skilled and effective. I would highly recommend him.

Lonnie Blanchard, Esq.

Blanchard • Holmes

Your willingness to continue to push for settlement and the ultimate shaking of hands at the end of the day was excellent and well worth the long day.

Richard D. Marks, Esq.

Floyd managed to settle a matter in mediation that I thought for sure would not settle that day. Bravo!

Mark Tseselsky, Esq.

With a case that I didn’t have much hope in settling, Mr. Siegal stuck with the parties, got us talking and found a way to settle the case. Not only was he persistent, but he went the extra mile after the actual mediation, volunteering his own time, to see that we reached a resolution. I would use him again in a heartbeat.

Adam Silverstein, Esq.

Cavalluzzi & Cavalluzzi

Floyd was very attentive throughout the mediation and made my client feel heard. Though we were not able to resolve the matter initially, Floyd followed up and continued to subtly move the parties forward, even when the parties themselves didn't think any more could be done, to the point where the matter settled. I would definitely recommend Floyd and look forward to working with him again.

Martin Moreno, Esq.

Pettit Kohn Ingrassia & Lutz

Mr. Siegal exhibited the finest attributes of a neutral mediator in bringing the parties together in the successful resolution of an emotionally charged case. Frankly, I was quite surprised at the results. I can't thank him enough for a job well done.

Robert M. Scholnick, Esq.


Grimm & Scholnick

I have had great success in using Mr. Siegal in mediating matters. He is very effective and goes to great lengths to assist settlement negotiations beyond what in my experience most mediators will do. He does this by thinking outside of the box in order to find compromise. Mr. Siegal has a genuine interest in facilitating the process so all parties understand what is needed to reach a resolution that is in everyone’s best interests. I look forward to utilizing his skill and expertise in the future.

Christopher P. Lyon, Esq.

Gilsleider & Trembath

I applaud you on your efforts and help in getting this settled. It was nothing less than masterful.

Larry Dornstein, Esq.

Mr. Siegal is extremely knowledgeable, patient and creative. His efforts went far beyond our expectations in settling our case. He is an excellent mediator and I highly recommend him. I look forward to working with him again in the near future.

Haleh Shekarchian, Esq.

Mr. Siegal was a wonderful mediator and was the main reason this case was able to settle. He was fair to both sides and explained the entire process to my client in a way she could understand. I would not hesitate to utilize his services in future cases.

Phillip M. Scuderi, Esq.

Mr. Siegal was very accommodating to the parties and worked steadfast in ensuring a resolution of a case that took many twists and turns during the course of the mediation. Great job.

Richard A. Harting, Esq.

Harting, Simkins & Ryan

Thank you for your patience and insight in this matter. It was really a pleasure to work with you on it, and a lesser mediator would not have gotten it done. As to the kind charitable contribution, the clients ask that you make the selection, since you did such a great job. Thanks again, and I know we will see you again soon.

Joseph Fogel, Esq.

Thank you for the fine job you did on Thursday. We had been through three prior mediations over the past four years, and were still a million dollars apart. You were able to cut that gap in half, and it was your guidance and encouragement that enabled us to take the final steps to finally settle the case on Friday afternoon. My clients are gratified and satisfied with the result.

Andy Roth, Esq.

Reid & Hellyer

Floyd's knowledge of the case and his approach to my clients led to the resolution of this matter. He was able to adapt to the personalities involved and zeroed in on the primary issues and practical aspects of the case.

Roderick D. Fong, Esq.

O'Rourke, Fong & Manoukian

I found Mr. Siegal to be an outstanding mediator. I believe he has the talent and personality to bridge enormous gaps. I would feel very comfortable using him or recommending him.

Neil Howard, Esq.