[Editor’s Note: This article first appeared in the inaugural edition of Resolution Strategies back in March of 2008, and was revised and updated in 2013 and then again in 2020. Eighteen years after its original publication, it still feels timely . . . perhaps timeless.]
Negotiation is generally considered more of an art than a science. To perfect the art of negotiation, my recommendation is simple: use numbers that paint the picture you want the other side to see.
An unreasonable opening demand or offer often impedes rather than promotes further negotiations. Similarly, a move that is too large may alter the other side’s expectations, while one that is too small may bring negotiations to a grinding halt.
Every negotiation begins with a blank canvas. With your first brushstroke, choose a number that realistically frames the dispute. With your next few moves, draw the two sides closer together without creating false expectations. If the other side has trouble picturing a range within which settlement might be possible, try a move that is bolder and more revealing, or, in the alternative, consider proposing a bracket.
Throughout the process, be aware of the patterns your numbers create. Whether intended or not, the size and sequence of your moves might be interpreted as signaling where you’re heading and how much farther you may be willing to go.
Even if you’re convinced that resolution is impossible, narrowing the gap still brings the picture into sharper focus. A negotiation that begins hundreds of thousands of dollars apart but ends only tens of thousands apart reveals something invaluable: the amount that genuinely separates the parties.
Painting a picture that enables the parties to make fully informed decisions is an art that everyone can appreciate.
As always, I would be pleased to assist you and your clients in the dispute resolution process. Please don’t hesitate to contact me if I can be of service.
Best regards,
Floyd J. Siegal